Home Blog Posts A South African Whovian’s perspective on Doctor Who Season 8

A South African Whovian’s perspective on Doctor Who Season 8


A few years ago (if I can recall correctly in 2011) – I heard about this really cool British sci-fi show called Doctor Who and was told that I should really start to watch it. I was quite skeptical – even though I love sci-fi and fantasy shows. We gave it a try and started watching the 11th Doctor’s series – with Matt Smith.

11th_doctor_wal_06 11doclineup

What a delightful surprise – with Matt’s fish fingers and custard and little Amy Pond. It took just one episode to hook us on the show. Since then we’ve watched Christopher Eccleston’s 9th doctor series with Rose Tyler and off course – the wonderful 10th doctor – David Tennant. My whole family also got enthralled by Doctor Who (Who wouldn’t – pun intended). Later on we also watched the older series and even the movies An Adventure in Space and Time as well as the 8th Doctor’s movie (eish not good, although I love the actor Paul McGann!).

a-town-called-mercy-poster the-angels-take-manhattan-poster

The beautiful music by composer Murray Gold, the excellent writing of Russel T Davis and later on Stephen Moffat, and the wonderful actors – we can honestly say we love Doctor Who. With the 50th anniversary show stopper with fantastic actor – Richard Hurt as the War Doctor and later on all three doctors together – what more could any fan ask for.

Puzzle 13 the snowmen

This created such anticipation for the next season…

However I must be honest and say that I am quite disappointed in the new season 8 with Peter Capaldi.

Why am I disappointed? It’s not so much the Peter Capaldi factor, but rather an issue I have with the story lines. I don’t know if it is on purpose, but goodness me – overall they are really bad. Out of the whole season 8, I must admit I enjoyed “Enter the Dalek” and “Flatline” episodes. The other episodes were really watered-down. I was also thinking – where is the fantastic music, the fanfare, the excitement, the amazing monsters. What happened? With the grand finale episodes – it was ok but not WOW!

thumbcapalditardis SPOILERS AHEAD

What’s the deal with Missy as The Master? Are they now preparing the way for a female Doctor Who?

I have a theory – we’ve been spoiled by wonderful doctors and stories the past few years – 9th, 10th, 11th and the War doctor – perhaps this is a strategy to boost the next “real” doctor – in season 9? Make season 8 ok-ish and then fire it off with a bang with Season 9 – with a doctor that people can relate to. Although Peter Capaldi is a good actor, the persona they are trying to carry through with this doctor is boring and does not fit in with the stories. At times I am thinking they are trying the Wibley Wobley Timey Whimey stuff with him (like in the Robin Hood episode and the spoon fight) and it really doesn’t work.

I’ve spoken to many other Whovians who feel the same. I honestly hope this will not be a repeat of the 7th Doctor – almost letting the whole series fail.

Even though this series is not great – I will still keep on watching. Once a Whovian, always a Whovian!



Some good news for Whovians, BBC Africa mentioned that Doctor Who series 8 with Peter Capaldi as the Twelfth Doctor will be premiering as an all-day marathon on BBC Entertainment South Africa on Saturday 27th December 2014 (at the time of publishing). 

See the official Christmas teaser trailer here:

Previous articleNerdiPop Doctor Who Week: The 12 (or is it 13) Doctors
Next articleSteam Black Friday / Thanksgiving sale